Call Today 303.622.3281
More on Drug Crimes

Supreme Court Rules On Use of Drug-Detecting Dogs Around the Home

If you are in your residence and, for whatever reason, are suspected of a drug crime, is it necessary for law enforcement to get a warrant before bringing a drug-detecting dog to the area immediately surrounding your house to test for the presence of drugs? The United States Supreme Court recently decided this issue, which will affect the Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable search and seizure-rights of suspects accused of drug crimes.

Background of the Case

The case arose out of Florida when law enforcement officers were investigating drug crimes. They received an anonymous tip that said that marijuana was being grown at a house. As a result, the officers went to the house and set up surveillance to monitor who left and approached the house.

When no one left or entered the house after time had passed, the officers called a colleague with a drug-detecting dog to the scene. The officer with the dog went to the front porch. When the dog reached the porch, he sat down near the door's threshold, indicating that there were drugs within the house.

Based on the dog's possible detection of drugs in the house, the officers obtained a search warrant for the premises. As the officers executed the warrant, the sole occupant of the house tried to flee out the back door, but was arrested. Upon a search of the house, officers found 179 marijuana plants, which were worth about $700,000. The suspect was then arrested for drug trafficking.

Was a Warrant Required?

At trial, the suspect's attorney objected to the introduction of the marijuana seized into evidence, arguing that the suspect's Fourth Amendment rights were violated, since officers failed to get a warrant before bringing the dog on the premises. The trial court and the Florida Supreme Court, on appeal, agreed with this argument, ruling that the evidence was inadmissible.

However, prosecutors decided to appeal the case to the U.S. Supreme Court for a final ruling. In a 5-4 decision, the court agreed with the lower courts that the bringing of the dog to the area immediately around the house to detect the possible presence of drugs constituted a "search" within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment. Because of this, the Constitution requires officers to get a warrant before they may bring a dog within close proximity of the premises.

The court's ruling strengthens everyone's right of privacy to the area immediately surrounding the home. In the past, the Supreme Court has ruled that in addition to the home itself, officers may not search the area immediately surrounding the home without getting a warrant first. This case makes it clear that the Fourth Amendment protections also apply to a drug-sniffing dog in addition to human officers.

As officers sometimes will skirt constitutional protections to make an arrest, if you have been accused of a drug crime, it is important to have the advice of an experienced criminal defense attorney. An attorney can ensure that your rights are protected throughout the process.

Contact me at (303) 622-3281 to discuss your case in a complimentary evaluation.

Tough Defense Strategies for Tough Criminal Charges

  • Fight to reduce, dismiss, or acquit your charges.

  • Keep you informed of your case at all times.

  • Available for evening, weekend appointments and jail visits.

  • Former first assistant federal public defender.

  • Complimentary and confidential consultations.

  • Will travel to you to hear your side of the story

Your Side of the Story Needs to Be Heard

  • “My case was handled with the utmost care and sincerity. I put my complete trust in David and my case was ultimately dismissed and charges dropped.”

    Alex

  • “David gave me confidence and did not allow the detective to "bully" me in any way. ”

    Jack

  • “I was blessed to have his help through such a difficult and challenging time.”

    Lauren

  • “Mr. Owen stayed in touch with me regularly, worked on my case beyond ordinary office hours, thoroughly explored all potential avenues of my defense.”

    Derek

  • “I found David to be extremely patient with my brother and me, especially during times where he probably had to re-explain the purpose of hearings and other court proceedings multiple times.”

    Christina

  • “Attorney Owen has many years of criminal experience and as he has done with me can guide anyone accused of a crime through a scary system and end up with the best outcome possible.”

    Richard

  • “David is someone whom was very knowledgeable and familiar with this specialty section of law.”

    Theresa

  • “He worked hard and got me a best case scenario in a bad situation.”

    Tony

  • “No words of thanks are enough for what Dave has done for my family and me. He was a Godsend. Until our last breath, we all are indebted to him.”

    Dr. Bhandary & Family

  • “David was a pleasure to work with and was always on top of things.”

    Keith

  • “David held my hand throughout the ordeal constantly reassuring me that I would be treated fairly and would get the best result possible.”

    Richard

Contact The Law Offices of David L. Owen, Jr.

    • Please enter your name.
    • This isn't a valid phone number.
    • Please enter your email address.
      This isn't a valid email address.
    • Please make a selection.
    • Please enter a message.